For small retail and hospitality businesses that need to build rotas, swap shifts and message hourly staff, When I Work, Deputy and Sling are the first three tools on this shortlist. It is written for owners and managers of small shift-based teams who want scheduling, time tracking and communication in one place. Homebase, Planday, Shiftbase and RotaCloud complete the list.
The shortlist
Side-by-side comparison
| Tool | Who it is for | Platforms | Pricing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small hourly teams that want scheduling, swaps and messaging in one mobile app | Mobile-first app; any iPad, POS system, laptop or phone can be used as a time clock | Pricing on wheniwork.com | |
| Small teams that want scheduling plus wage costs, compliance and payroll hours | Schedules created and shared from any device | Pricing on deputy.com | |
| Small restaurants, cafes, hotels and shops that need rotas, trades and staff messaging | Web, iOS and Android | Pricing on getsling.com | |
| Small hourly businesses that want scheduling, payroll and hiring in one app | Mobile-first app; time clocks on mobile or tablet; clock in from any device | Pricing on joinhomebase.com | |
| Hospitality and retail teams that want rule-checked rotas and one communication hub | Cloud-based; mobile app on iOS and Android; time tracking from mobile or terminal | Pricing on planday.com | |
| European hospitality and shift-based businesses that want payroll-ready hours | Employee app and terminal clock-in; full platform list not stated on official pages | Pricing on shiftbase.com | |
| Small cafes, bars, restaurants and care homes that want straightforward rotas and leave | Fully web-based; apps for staff | Pricing on rotacloud.com |
Quick verdict by need
- When I Work if you need small hourly teams that want scheduling, swaps and messaging in one mobile app.
- Deputy if you need small teams that want scheduling plus wage costs, compliance and payroll hours.
- Sling if you need small restaurants, cafes, hotels and shops that need rotas, trades and staff messaging.
- Homebase if you need small hourly businesses that want scheduling, payroll and hiring in one app.
- Planday if you need hospitality and retail teams that want rule-checked rotas and one communication hub.
- Shiftbase if you need european hospitality and shift-based businesses that want payroll-ready hours.
Tool details

#1 · When I Work, Inc.
When I Work
Small hourly teams that want scheduling, swaps and messaging in one mobile app

When I Work is a mobile-first workforce management app that combines shift scheduling, time tracking and team messaging for hourly, shift-based teams.
Documented strengths
- Managers build schedules quickly and offer OpenShifts to fill gaps
- Time-off requests, open shifts and shift swaps handled in the app
- Auto-scheduler matches shifts to eligibility, availability and preferences
- GPS clock-ins and geofencing
- Payroll sync with Rippling, ADP, QuickBooks and Gusto
Documented limits
Documented for hourly workers on the floor or in the field, so salaried or office-based teams should check the vendor documentation. Payroll sync is documented for the named platforms only.
- Who it is for
- Small hourly teams that want scheduling, swaps and messaging in one mobile app
- Platforms
- Mobile-first app; any iPad, POS system, laptop or phone can be used as a time clock
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. wheniwork.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It sits first because the vendor describes it as designed exclusively for hourly workers, with quick schedule building, OpenShifts and shift swaps handled in one app.

#2 · Deputy
Deputy
Small teams that want scheduling plus wage costs, compliance and payroll hours

Deputy is an employee scheduling, timekeeping, HR and payroll platform with AI labor forecasting, built for shift-based teams.
Documented strengths
- Drag and drop scheduling from any device
- Staff manage availability, swap shifts and clock in themselves
- Live wage cost tracking
- Compliance tools for breaks, Fair Workweek, overtime and custom pay rules
- Demand forecasting using sales, delivery orders and appointments
Documented limits
It is positioned as a complete platform covering HR, analytics and compliance, so a business that only needs a simple rota may use a small part of it. Teams should check the vendor documentation for their payroll provider.
- Who it is for
- Small teams that want scheduling plus wage costs, compliance and payroll hours
- Platforms
- Schedules created and shared from any device
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. deputy.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It comes second because drag-and-drop scheduling, staff-managed swaps and availability suit small teams, though its wider HR and compliance scope goes beyond a basic rota.

#3 · Sling (Toast)
Sling
Small restaurants, cafes, hotels and shops that need rotas, trades and staff messaging

Sling is employee shift scheduling and planning software that also offers time tracking, team messaging and labor cost tools. It is now branded Sling by Toast.
Documented strengths
- Time off, availability and shift trade requests handled while building schedules
- Schedules saved as templates
- Group and private messaging
- Real-time shift labor costs with a warning when a shift exceeds the labor budget
- Admin, Manager and Employee access levels
Documented limits
Documented for exporting timesheets for payroll processing rather than direct payroll, so teams should check the vendor documentation for payroll integrations.
- Who it is for
- Small restaurants, cafes, hotels and shops that need rotas, trades and staff messaging
- Platforms
- Web, iOS and Android
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. getsling.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It sits third because it pairs shift-trade handling and templates with group and private messaging, and names restaurants, coffee shops, hotels and retail stores as its audience.

#4 · Homebase
Homebase
Small hourly businesses that want scheduling, payroll and hiring in one app

Homebase is a mobile-first app for small businesses with hourly teams that combines scheduling, time clocks, payroll, hiring, HR and team communication.
Documented strengths
- Time clocks with PIN, photo and GPS/geofencing verification
- Automatic flags for missed punches, breaks and overtime
- Built-in payroll with tax filing, direct deposit and tip pooling
- Hiring tools for job posts, screening and interview booking
- AI assistants for schedules, hiring and payroll error detection
Documented limits
The payroll product is described with U.S.-style tax filings, so businesses elsewhere should check the vendor documentation. Teams that only need rotas may not use the payroll and hiring tools.
- Who it is for
- Small hourly businesses that want scheduling, payroll and hiring in one app
- Platforms
- Mobile-first app; time clocks on mobile or tablet; clock in from any device
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. joinhomebase.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It follows Sling because it covers scheduling and communication but is broader, adding payroll and hiring, which matters most to teams wanting one app for everything.

#5 · Planday
Planday
Hospitality and retail teams that want rule-checked rotas and one communication hub

Planday is a cloud-based workforce management platform for employee scheduling, time tracking, communication and staff management.
Documented strengths
- Staff message each other and request shift swaps and handovers in the app
- Communication hub replaces scattered messaging channels
- Alerts managers when a schedule or shift breaks a configured rule
- Working time rules and leave and holiday policies
- Reports and forecasts to predict staffing needs
Documented limits
Documented for shift-working businesses from small to enterprise size, so the rule configuration may be more than a very small team needs. Check the vendor documentation for payroll integrations.
- Who it is for
- Hospitality and retail teams that want rule-checked rotas and one communication hub
- Platforms
- Cloud-based; mobile app on iOS and Android; time tracking from mobile or terminal
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. planday.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It sits fifth because it documents shift swaps, handovers and a communication hub that replaces scattered messaging channels, and offers product tours tailored to hospitality.

#6 · Shiftbase
Shiftbase
European hospitality and shift-based businesses that want payroll-ready hours

Shiftbase is workforce software for shift-based businesses in Europe that combines scheduling, time tracking, absence management and payroll-ready hours.
Documented strengths
- Auto-scheduling drafts a schedule from availability and contract hours
- Employees swap and claim shifts in the app and managers approve them
- Approved hours export to payroll without re-entry
- Receives turnover from POS systems
- Wage data stored on European servers under GDPR
Documented limits
Documented for businesses in Europe, with payroll integrations such as Nmbrs, Loket, AFAS and Exact Online. Businesses elsewhere should check the vendor documentation. Revenue and labour cost visibility is an add-on module.
- Who it is for
- European hospitality and shift-based businesses that want payroll-ready hours
- Platforms
- Employee app and terminal clock-in; full platform list not stated on official pages
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. shiftbase.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It sits sixth because employees can swap and claim shifts in the app and auto-scheduling uses stored availability, but the vendor focuses on shift teams across Europe.

#7 · RotaCloud
Rotacloud
Small cafes, bars, restaurants and care homes that want straightforward rotas and leave

RotaCloud is cloud-based rota software for planning shifts, managing leave and tracking time and attendance, with staff apps.
Documented strengths
- Rota planning, leave requests and timesheets in one system
- Holiday management with allowances and usage patterns
- Staff clock in by app or on-site, with hours feeding payroll preparation
- Reports on daily and monthly staffing costs by role, site and department
- Reports on open shifts picked up or left unclaimed
Documented limits
The official facts do not describe shift swaps or team messaging, so teams that need those should check the vendor documentation. The company states it is GDPR compliant.
- Who it is for
- Small cafes, bars, restaurants and care homes that want straightforward rotas and leave
- Platforms
- Fully web-based; apps for staff
- Pricing
- See the vendor's own pricing page for current plans and costs. rotacloud.com
- Facts checked
- 21 November 2026
Why it is placed here: It closes the list because it is built around simple rota planning and leave for small and medium businesses, but the documentation says less about shift-swap and messaging features than the earlier tools.
Sources
- When I Work: wheniwork.com, wheniwork.com/about, wheniwork.com/security (21 Nov 2026)
- Deputy: deputy.com, deputy.com/about, deputy.com/features (21 Nov 2026)
- Sling: getsling.com, getsling.com/about-us, getsling.com/features-2 (21 Nov 2026)
- Homebase: joinhomebase.com, joinhomebase.com/about-us, joinhomebase.com/security (21 Nov 2026)
- Planday: planday.com, planday.com/about, planday.com/how-it-works (21 Nov 2026)
- Shiftbase: shiftbase.com, shiftbase.com/about-us, shiftbase.com/industries/security (21 Nov 2026)
- Rotacloud: rotacloud.com, rotacloud.com/about, rotacloud.com/features (21 Nov 2026)
Related guides
How we compiled this
We looked at how closely each tool fits the work of building rotas, handling shift swaps and communicating with hourly staff. The criteria were documented scheduling and swap features, messaging and communication tools, time tracking, and what the vendor documents about apps and platforms. We prefer tools whose official pages describe hourly, shift-based teams in retail or hospitality.
All facts come from each vendor's official pages, and each page carries a check date. The order reflects editorial fit for this use case, closest fit first, and the reason for each position is explained in words next to the tool. It does not say any tool is better overall. The list is built from vendor documentation, not from product trials, so teams with specific needs should confirm details with the vendor. Pricing is not covered here; each vendor has its own pricing page.
Order used: Ordered by simplicity of rota building and shift-swap features for hourly teams, closest fit first.
Common questions
What is the easiest way to build a rota for hourly staff?
Look for drag-and-drop or automatic scheduling. Deputy uses drag and drop tools, When I Work has an auto-scheduler that matches shifts to eligibility, availability and preferences, and Shiftbase drafts a schedule from stored availability and contract hours.
Which scheduling apps let staff swap shifts?
When I Work lets managers handle shift swaps from the app, and Deputy lets staff swap shifts themselves. Sling handles shift trade requests, Planday supports swaps and handovers, and Shiftbase lets employees swap and claim shifts, with managers approving.
Can these tools message hourly staff?
Yes, several document messaging. When I Work includes team messaging, Sling has group and private messaging, and Planday has a communication hub that replaces scattered messaging channels. Homebase documents team communication as part of its app.
Do shift scheduling tools connect to payroll?
Many do. When I Work syncs with Rippling, ADP, QuickBooks and Gusto, Deputy can send approved timesheets to Paycor, and Homebase has built-in payroll. Sling can export timesheets, and Shiftbase exports approved hours to payroll.
Which tools are suited to small hospitality businesses?
Sling names restaurants and coffee shops, Planday offers hospitality-focused product tours, and RotaCloud names restaurants, cafes and bars. Shiftbase also names hospitality, but is focused on businesses in Europe.
The editorial order is unpaid. A vendor can buy one labelled featured slot per guide, but it gets the same fact check as everyone else and cannot alter or remove a competitor's entry. Guidehurst is independent. Product names and logos belong to their respective owners.
